Playing Chess With Pigeons

 

by Loz Lawrey

I’ve been hearing terms such as “postmodernism”, “neo-marxism” and “the left” bandied about by right-wing commentators ever more frequently lately, so, in order to clarify my own understanding of the meaning of these verbal brickbats, I’ve been doing some googling.

I’ve always thought of myself as a leftie, and proud of it. A communist or socialist? Perhaps, though if a label must be chosen, I prefer the term “progressive”.

But am I a postmodernist or a neo-Marxist? “Yes and no”, said Professor Google. “You are and you aren’t”, because these terms are extremely difficult to explain and many conflicting, often contradictory definitions exist.

That’s the trouble with “isms”. Their actual meaning is loose, fluid and subject to interpretation.

According to Google, “communism” is “a theory or system of social organization in which all property is owned by the community and each person contributes and receives according to their ability and needs.”

Now to me, that doesn’t sound too bad. In fact, if I had to select a recipe for social organisation, welfare and cohesion, then some version of communism or socialism would be my choice. An inclusive “best for all” system which makes everyone a winner.

When right-wing pundits use the term “communism” however, it implies evil of the worst order.

Communism is portrayed as the enemy of capitalism, of “freedom” (however we define that), of our first-world right to selfish greed and exclusive self-advancement.

Former Prime Minister John Howard once described the very idea of a banking royal commission as “rampant socialism”. I’m still trying to make sense of that statement. I think he meant that a royal commission would be a bad thing.

Conservative politicians regularly conflate communism with unions and social activism generally.

What are these forces working so hard to drag the sensible centre of politics and governance towards the far right, those barren lands where chaos and deregulated anarchy prevail?

What does “the right” actually want? From where I’m sitting, it looks like a vision of dystopia, a post-apocalyptic disaster zone where a few mega-wealthy “winners” lord it over a population of starving, miserable, downtrodden losers.

I may be on the wrong planet. The problem may be me. I do acknowledge the possibility. Or, I may simply be ageing and struggling to accommodate a changing world, one in which my “givens” no longer apply.

You know, old-fashioned concepts such as: Decency should guide us. Empathy is good. Inclusion is essential. Racism, misogyny, bigotry and religious zealotry are destructive and anti-social. We should care for each other and support our most vulnerable etc, etc….

There’s a meme that regularly circulates on Facebook: A picture of a pigeon on a chessboard knocking the pieces over, with this caption:

“Arguing with conservatives is like playing chess with a pigeon: No matter how good you are at chess, the pigeon is just going to knock over the pieces, crap on the board and then strut around acting like it won.”

At times I myself have tried unsuccessfully to argue with that pigeon.

I can confirm that it’s a complete waste of time. Don’t even bother.

It’s as if Planet Earth is inhabited by two tribes, with the members of one wearing blue-tinted spectacles and members of the other red. Both tribes are looking at the same world, yet seeing completely disparate landscapes.

Language is difficult. If I say “table”, do you visualise a round, square or rectangular one? Large or small? Made of timber or otherwise? Perhaps that’s why they say “a picture’s worth a thousand words”. At least when we look at a picture we are seeing the same thing.

“There’s a war on empathy” commented singer/activist Billy Bragg on a recent visit to Australia. Who could disagree? Well… possibly “left”-hating conservatives who approve of Australia’s inhumane treatment of refugees?

At the time Malcolm Turnbull was entreating us not to get “misty-eyed” over his regime’s ongoing human rights abuses.

Is there a war on thinking? Anyone observing the toxic outpourings from the Murdoch media, the shallowness of journalism, the decrease in literacy or the Coalition’s defunding and dumbing-down of the ABC might think so.

Right-wing attacks on universities as cauldrons of “leftism” make one wonder: what is the “right” afraid of? Is it “leftism” or thought itself?

Might it be that universities are in fact incubators of ideologies of empathy and social inclusion precisely because they are centres of thought and learning?

I ask again: What does “the right”  actually want? What is the conservative vision? Is there one? If there is, I’m damned if I can see it. Perhaps I’m wearing the wrong glasses.

I know I can describe the kind of world I would prefer to live in, and it’s a warm and friendly place, where people actually care… I’m guessing that makes me a stupid old leftie hippie.

Conservatives are well-practised at criticising and condemning, but whenever I ask one to articulate their coherent vision for a better world all I get are insults such as “leftard”.

In other words, crap on the chessboard.

Leave a Reply

mask-with-filter   reusable-mask   washable-mask   face-masks   best-face-masks   do-face-masks-work   lush-face-masks   diy-face-masks   face-masks-for-acne   korean-face-masks   best-face-masks-for-acne   cpap-masks-full-face   natural-face-masks   freeman-face-masks   walmart-face-masks   face-masks-diy   face-masks-walmart   cool-face-masks   how-to-make-face-masks   what-do-face-masks-do   good-face-masks   homemade-face-masks   do-face-masks-expire   face-masks-for-men   best-korean-face-masks   3m-mask   3m-respirator-mask   3m-n95-mask   3m-dust-mask   3m-face-mask   3m-gas-mask   3m-mask-filters   3m-full-face-mask   3m-filter-mask   3m-p100-mask   3m-half-mask   publix-pharmacy   mask   heb-pharmacy   face-mask   gloves   masks   rite-aid-stock   publix-pharmacy-near-me   disposable   face-masks   rite-aid-stock-price   procedural   cvs-near-me-now   target-patio-furniture   facea   vons-pharmacy   surgical-mask   mouth-mask   facemask   ebay-adult   fqace   medical-mask   amazon-fsa   ㄹㅁㅊㄷ   publix-easy-ordering   allheart-scrubs   good-morning-america-steals-and-deals   facial-mask   laryngeal-mask-airway   medical-gloves   walgreens-invitations   shein-outlet   t&t-nails   allergy-mask   latex-mask   gma-deals-and-steals-today-2019   lma-airway   surgical-masks   986-pharmacy   amed-stock   facemasks   walmart-ear-plugs   medical-face-mask   rite-aid-san-diego   mouth-masks   walgreens-orlando-fl   pface   pollen-count-nj   face-mask-amazon   target-bath-mat   masks-for-sale   pollen-count-tampa   sick-mask   pollen-mask   dog-cone-walmart   cough-mask   walmart-item-locator   surgical-face-mask   dental-salon   costco-custom-cakes   hospital-mask   rite-care-pharmacy   face-cover   pollen-count-las-vegas   flu-mask   facial-masks   black-surgical-mask   face-cover-mask   mask-face   up&up   sick-face   the-mask-3   latex-glove   costco-air-filter   walgreens-allergy-medicine   amazon-face-mask   mouth-cover   medical-masks   ralphs-pharmacy-near-me   walmart-sale-paper   cvs-pharmacy-san-diego   walgreens-birthday-invitations   dust-mask-walmart   face-mask-walmart   protective-mask   no-face-mouth   walmart-face-masks   face-masks-walmart   face-mask-sick   walgreens-medical-supplies   walgreens-medical-supply-store   disposable-face-mask   walgreens-sale-paper   laryngeal-mask   heb-prices   kids-face-mask   face}   walgreens-tampa,-fl   humidifier-costco   target-face-mask   heb-plus-pharmacy   whose-face-was-used-to-make-the-mask-in-the-movie-halloween   how-to-make-a-face-mask   how-often-should-you-use-a-face-mask   how-often-should-i-use-a-face-mask   how-often-should-you-do-a-face-mask   respirator   respirator-mask   n95-respirator   3m-respirator   full-face-respirator   p100-respirator   n95-respirator-mask   respirator-fit-test   paint-respirator   welding-respirator   n-95-respirator   3m-full-face-respirator   papr-respirator   3m-respirator-mask   particulate-respirator   supplied-air-respirator   home-depot-respirator   mold-respirator   half-mask-respirator   lowes-respirator   respirator-mask   n95-respirator-mask   3m-respirator-mask   half-mask-respirator   full-face-respirator-mask   respirator-mask-lowes   face-mask-respirator   respirator-mask-for-mold   respirator-mask-walmart   best-respirator-mask   respirator-mask-for-chemical-fumes   chemical-respirator-mask   full-mask-respirator   half-face-respirator-mask